Pages

Monday, July 14, 2008

Mr. C

Image credit: Photo by
nimou on Flickr

Today my daughter was chattering away, chattering to herself or her toys, chattering things that have meaning only to her. "Mr. C, C Mr., Mr. C...," she chanted.

And I could see his too-friendly grin approaching, like the wolf in Little Red Riding Hood: my high school English teacher ready to bend a little too close over my work, place his hands on my shoulders, touch me a little too long and a little too intimately... His full name was multisyllabic and difficult to pronounce, so he went by the initial: Mr. C. But we teenage girls had other names for Mr. C, names like "sleazy" and "perverted" and "gross." Mr. C. Behind his back we called him Mr. Creepy.

I forgot about Mr. C for the most part, until many years later when I read in the newspaper that he had resigned from his teaching position amidst controversy regarding inappropriate sexual relationships with some of his students. While this came as no surprise to me, I wondered now, as an adult, why it never occurred to any of us to do anything other than whisper amongst ourselves about our discomfort. We never told an administrator or a parent, and we never told him no. While we were younger than Mr. C, we weren't children anymore, at least in the eyes of the law; his pupils, his targets, were all above the age of consent. So, I suppose we assumed that everyone knew, that we were supposed to take care of ourselves, and above all that there wasn't anything wrong enough with someone who touched just a little too much or a little too long, with someone who looked just a little too hungrily and complimented our looks a little too eagerly.

Of course, something else has changed about the way I look at Mr. C now. I have a new name for him. Yes, if you've spent any time reading here at all, you probably guessed it: sex addict. I know that there are still plenty of people who would stick to calling him a creep or a pervert or simply a misogynistic jerk. There are plenty of people who would explain his actions as those of someone who is morally bankrupt or recklessly hedonistic or lacking in self control. There might even be those men, um, I mean, people who would defend his advances toward female students, and his romantic relationships with some of them, by saying the girls were legally adults, capable of handling themselves, and he was "just doing what any guy would do."

But for me, all those labels and explanations dismiss him without changing anything. They all say: he is what he is. Born or made, some people are just disgusting jerks (or bold and lucky dogs), right? But I call Mr. C a sex addict, and while that means much the same thing to most people, to me it doesn't mean dismissal or judgment; it means hope. Sex addiction is a disease, a type of compulsive behavior, and diseases can be treated. There is no hope for Mr. Creepy, but when I think of him as Mr. Compulsive instead, the door to change is just waiting to be opened.

"Mr. C, C Mr. Mr. C...," she chants on. Someday my daughter will encounter a man like that. We all do at some point. And when she does, I hope she greets him with both with firmer boundaries and more compassion than I did. I hope she can say no and speak her truth to the world without dismissing him as worthless and hopeless.

22 comments:

  1. Stagnant ArtistJul 14, 2008 01:56 PM
    yep i think all schools had them... mine was the computer teacher. rumors about him hooking up with students... i just saw loser. and thought the same of the girls.
    ReplyDelete
  2. I had a teacher like Mr. C as well; like your peers, we did nothing to call attention to our teacher's horrific behaviour even though we knew better (having been raised by a mother who experienced incest as a child, I really did know better).

    Prior to reading your painfully honest and uplifting blog, it would never have occurred to me to treat the Mr. Cs out there with any sort of compassion at all. I lack compassion, severely, but I'm learning it thanks in large part to you.

    You have helped me become a better and more compassionate woman, and I greatly admire your own courage and compassion.
    ReplyDelete
  3. your compassion and understanding continues to amaze me. you are truly a forgiving, understanding, humane woman. i want to be like you when i grow up!

    luv and hugs,
    e
    ReplyDelete
  4. Sophie in the MoonlightJul 14, 2008 05:19 PM
    Your daughter will have the gifts of knowledge and empowerment. She is your daughter. She will know no other way than to speak her truth. She will also know when compassion is called for and when the police should be called for. She will be strong and she will be just. She will be yours.
    ReplyDelete
  5. The door to change is just waiting to be opened.

    Wish more people had your attitude.
    :)
    ReplyDelete
  6. This post raised an interesting practical question in my mind - you mention that you hope your daughter will "meet him with firmer boundaries". I agree completely, and hope I can raise my daughter the same. But what is the practical way to meet a teacher with firmer boundaries? We had those teachers too, I can't think of a way to respond as a student. My usual answer to this sort of thing - humour escalating to sarcasm - I just can't see working for a school kid. Does your perspective give some insight here?
    ReplyDelete
  7. It was our middle school guidance counselor. I was in trouble because my shorts were too short, so I was sent into his office to determine whether or not I had to be sent home. There was this rule where your shorts had to go past the spot where your hands ended on your legs if you held them straight down. Mine were pretty even...

    But anyway, the guidance counselor had me come in his office and shut the door. He asked me to stand up and show him where my hands fell on my shorts. He looked at me for a long time, and then he asked me to turn around, and he looked at me from behind for a longer time. I felt like he was pouring mud all over me with his eyes.

    And I did nothing. I told my girlfriends and we giggled and shuddered together.
    ReplyDelete
  8. I'm thinking about alcoholics and how it's ok to be one, to go about recovery in your own time, so long as you don't drink and drive. There's a line there. And with sex addicts, I'm thinking it's ok to be in need of recovery but just don't teach our children or young people. Not sure if the analogy is right...just pondering the line.

    I hope you're having a good summer, MPJ. Leaving you a hug.
    ReplyDelete
  9. So what's the overlap between sex addict and pedophile? Is there any? And between sex addict and rapist?

    I'm not convinced the Mr. C's of the world are sex addicts. High school students are young. They come to high school as girls, nearly or actually children. The difference between 14 and 18 is not a line, it's a chasm. OK, if he was fondling fully developed teenagers, he probably wasn't a pedophile - but there's something about the power differential that still strikes me as different from purely sexual contact.

    Rape isn't about sex, it's about power, and I think a lot of sexual relationships where there's a big power differential are also not as much about sex as they are about power.

    He is still deserving of compassion because everyone is, but I'm just not sure that sex addiction completely explains his actions.
    ReplyDelete
  10. Misery MarketingJul 15, 2008 12:11 AM
    Maybe I can cut this guys some slack but just a little younger I agree with Dennis Miller. People who are compelled to abuse children should kill themselves. Take one for the team as Dennis puts it. Funny though about not doing anything cause last night me and a friend sitting on the front porch and watched two guys who just popped up outta no where walking around looking into cars to see if there was anything worth breaking into them for. They were so close there was nothing we could really do. I was terrified. They actually had the nerve to bum a cigarette. I thought I was gonna get mugged fo sho! I had like $700 in my wallet so I was really upset. Luckily we didnt look like the types to have wallets full of cash. Nothing happened except a couple minutes later we heard a car alarm a block over. We didnt call the cops. Why? I dunno. Fear of retaliation maybe?
    ReplyDelete
  11. Mary P Jones (MPJ)Jul 15, 2008 12:15 AM
    Ariane, when I think about how I'd like my daughter to handle the same situation, I'd like her to be able to say to the teacher "I don't feel comfortable with you touching me. Please stop." And to tell other adults (parents, administrators) if that boundary was not respected.

    I teach both of my children that they have a right to decide when and how other people touch them, even if that touch is a "friendly" one -- like a handshake or a hug.
    ReplyDelete
  12. ah, yes Mr. C.
    I had one, or three or six of those myself through high school and into college.
    I, of course, like your perspective, the way you see things. I wish more people could explore the possibilities beyond creep.
    What strikes me, scares me in some way, when looking back is to realize, remember how basically normal I found the whole thing, how normal everyone found it.
    ReplyDelete
  13. I'm resonating pretty strongly with what Jay said, also with Mary Ann's point about active alcoholics. The underlying problem with someone like Mr. C is that he's attracted to very young women, but has deliberately put himself into a work situation where he has both access and authority. He may be an addict, ok, but more importantly he is a predator. Why it's so confusing for his victims is that he's working the power dyanamic in his favor, and that's where you cross the line from ill to evil.
    ReplyDelete
  14. Mary P Jones (MPJ)Jul 15, 2008 01:09 AM
    Jay, sex addiction isn't about sex either, of course.

    As for the lines between sex offenses and sex addiction: I remember reading, very early on in recovery, Patrick Carnes' statement that not all pedophiles and rapists are sex addicts and vice versa, of course.

    While the vast majority of sex addicts are not sex offenders, there are certainly sex offenders out on probation in my husband's SAA group. So, yes. There is overlap.

    Because so many people confuse the two already and assume that ALL sex addicts are sex offenders, and because sex offenses are such an emotional topic (much more than infidelity even), I hesitated to go even this far toward that territory because I didn't want ignite a firestorm or perpetuate a myth.

    In the instance I wrote about, from what I know of the case through personal and secondhand experience, the girls were older and the sexual relationships took place with college age girls, although "befriending" them took place in late high school. Thus, I'm (in this post) avoiding the question while bringing it up by implication. Terrible of me, I know.

    The truth is that I simply don't feel comfortable exploring that overlap or talking about where to draw lines in that grey area right now. You and I can talk privately, if you'd like, but it's not something I'm ready or willing to discuss on the blog right now.
    ReplyDelete
  15. Mary P Jones (MPJ)Jul 15, 2008 01:11 AM
    Bella, yes! How normal it all was is completely creepy to me now. I hope that it will not be normal to my daughter. I fear it will still be normal to her friends.
    ReplyDelete
  16. I never ran into this in high school, but college was teeming with all sorts of sex addict professors.

    I have to admit that this post touched a raw spot in me, though--I'm very, very bothered by sex addicts who act out on young people (even those who are above the age of consent). It's much more difficult for me to find compassion for them than addicts who act out with adults.
    ReplyDelete
  17. Mary P Jones (MPJ)Jul 15, 2008 01:45 AM
    Mary Ann and Lise, I'd agree that someone like this shouldn't be (and isn't anymore, in this case) teaching. That's one of the reasons I would hope my daughter would speak up in a situation like this.

    Lise, yours is a hard comment to address, since I don't personally believe there is any such thing as evil. Evil, for me, requires a kind on conscious, rational intentionality that I just don't think is present in the people who do horrific things.

    But you have me musing about where the line is drawn between a teacher who likes young women and a grocery store manager who hits on his employees and an army captain who hits on those in his command. I don't think society sees those all as equally reprehensible, even when the women in question are the same age.
    ReplyDelete
  18. Interesting comments by all. Teachers to me have a certain "moral code" that society holds them to. Parents begin entrusting their children to them from a young age and it is in a very real sense the first institutionalization of society children experience. In this way I feel they hold more power with the student than other forms of authority.

    As for the difference between sexual predator and sex addict...whoa! This is so new to me but I never thought of putting them in the same category.

    mpj,

    I get the point you are making though and respect it. I am currently reviewing the witnessing of my father's sexual behavior toward adult women in my childhood. I have far more compassion when I recognize it as sexual addiction. My view of it has softened as I realize it came from his own inner pain and his powerlessness. For me it seems you are truly trying to say we are all human and deserve compassion. As for our children...if they can stand firm in their boundaries but hold a clearer view of where this is coming from within another (inner pain) it holds less pain, less power or impact on the child.
    ReplyDelete
  19. Slutty McWhoreJul 15, 2008 12:33 PM
    I'm on Jay with this one. I just don't think the term "sex addict" is the correct one for someone like Mr C. In fact, I'm not even sure the term "sex addict" is adequate for anybody really, as I think there are such varied experiences/habits/compulsions etc. in the people who go to SLAA or SAA meetings. One simple label doesn't do them justice.

    In my job, I meet quite a lot of people I'd consider to be "sex addicts" and yet I don't necessarily find their behaviour creepy. Sad, yes, pathetic, maybe, but not creepy. There is just something about Mr C being a teacher, and the abuse of power that goes with it, that really disgusts me.

    I never had a teacher like him, but I did have a driving instructor who would move his leg closer to the gear stick every time I had to change the gear, because he knew that would mean I'd have to touch his thigh. Even if he hadn't done that, the guy creeped me out from the beginning. I never said anything to my parents about it because I was embarrassed, and didn't know what to say. I was also too young to confront him about it. He knew both of these things, and that's why I see his behaviour as an abuse of power. Not all sex addicts manipulate or consciously abuse others as this guy, and Mr C, did.
    ReplyDelete
  20. I don't know how I feel exactly about this complicated topic, but I am glad to read about it and see these different points of views. Makes me think.
    ReplyDelete
  21. I encountered my Mr. C in a shop class in junior high. I never said anything either. No one ever told me about situations like that. I think the key is to educate our kids about people who do these things and encourage them to speak up.

    The comments on this post are quite interesting. I am glad to hear Mr. C is no longer teaching, I wish it could have been quite earlier.
    ReplyDelete
  22. We’ve all encountered him … and it’s hard not to ‘judge’ (even though we’re cautioned to judge not). Understanding and compassion are acquired abilities (once we’ve lost or had them drummed out of ourselves as children), but it’s good to be reminded that we can be understanding & compassionate AND maintain healthy boundaries & limits when we pay attention. Thanks …
    Hugs and blessings,
    ReplyDelete