Pages

Sunday, July 6, 2008

Confused Recovery Nerds on Hancock

Will Smith's Hancock
tells us we deserve better.

Mark and I went out to see Hancock last night. We were really looking forward to this one: July 4th weekend opening, Will Smith, superhero antics and alcoholism. It was slated to have everything!

And the first half of the movie delivered on its blockbuster promises. Will Smith was delightfully hilarious in his drunken belligerence and blaming. Like a good active addict, he destroyed everything he touched. Jason Bateman as Ray Embrey, Hancock's PR man, was the movie's codependent, out to fix him right. It was actually a refreshing twist to see a codependent role played out by a male buddy character rather than a female love interest.

Hancock, at Ray's insistence, starts attending meetings for alcoholism. I appreciated the fact that these meetings involved less crosstalk and less of an active leader role than the typical Hollywood screen versions of 12 Step, most of which employ these inaccuracies as narrative devices. (I'll have to do a separate post sometime on Hollywood 12 Step.) And Hancock reminded me of myself in early S-Anon meetings: saying nothing and listening grudgingly, although I liked his first share better than mine.

Yep, the first half of the movie had it all. There was action. There were laughs. There were 12 Step meetings and redemption. Then, it seemed to Mark and me, the writer died right there in the middle of the script. It was like that scene in Monty Python and the Holy Grail where Brother Maynard reads the last words of Joseph of Arimathea carved on a cave wall: "He who is valiant, and pure of spirit, may find the Holy Grail, in the Castle of... Aaaaaagggh." He speculates that Joseph died while carving and Galahad chimes in (in one of the movies many great lines), "Perhaps he was dictating."

It truly seemed as if someone new took over in the middle and wrote a completely different story, one which made no sense. It wasn't funny or dramatic or gripping. It was just jaw droppingly nonsensical. You'll notice, as I did, after you see the movie that every single scene from the trailer is one that takes place in the first (good) half of the movie.

So, here's my recommendation to you on Hancock. Go and see it. And when you are about halfway in, there will be a scene where Hancock puts on his new superhero outfit and is called in to rescue a female police officer. (I'm not giving anything away here; this is all in the trailer.) At the end of that scene, get up and walk out. You will have seen a complete story, from down and out bitterness to redemption. You will have seen everything funny and worthwhile and exciting in the movie. You will leave happy and feel it was money well spent, even if the movie was on the short side. You won't sit there for the rest of the movie wishing he were doing anger management classes with the villains (oh, that would have been delightful and funny) instead of "fighting" them, such as they are. You won't leave thinking, "What the hell was that about? And I wonder how that first writer died."

And for those of you girls and boys who enjoy ogling Will Smith's firm and well-formed behind, allow me to alert you to the fact that, like I Robot before it, Hancock did contain one gratuitous Will Smith bare butt cheek shot. It even came conveniently packaged with the line "my ass was hot," which allowed you to giggle and say, "Yes. Yes it was." And as with all good things in this movie, the scene even came in the movie's glorious first half, so you won't miss it if take my advice and walk out halfway through the show.



The Discovering Alcoholic has his review of Hancock up too, if you want to check it out.

17 comments:

  1. The Discovering AlcoholicJul 6, 2008 05:14 AM
    Sounds like the recovery nerds are in full agreement on this MPJ. I am still very much a Will SMith fan, but this movie fizzled out early.
    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a wonderful review. If I get to see Hancock, which I would like to do, I shall try to take your advice. It's very useful to know where the good parts end.
    ReplyDelete
  3. Mary P Jones (MPJ)Jul 6, 2008 09:53 AM
    Discovering Alcoholic, yep, I'm with you. But you probably didn't enjoy the Will Smith butt scene as much as I did. ;)
    ReplyDelete
  4. We almost went to see this today. I am glad we did not. I think I will wait till DVD.
    ReplyDelete
  5. I'll wait for PPV...thanks for the heads up!
    ReplyDelete
  6. My husband and I went to see this on Saturday and had exactly the same response. You nailed it.
    ReplyDelete
  7. ROFL!! Having seen Hancock I know exactly what you are talking about and couldn't agree more. Dh and I did walk out of there saying "what the hell was that?". lol
    ReplyDelete
  8. We watched it and we loved it!
    ReplyDelete
  9. Interesting. I checked out the reviews on line and they are pretty much in unison with yours. Most critics agree that it just didn't fly when it made the abrupt switch.

    I have never watched any of the Matrix flicks. Since your many references to it I have tried to rent the first one and it is never available so I trust your movie reviews.
    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanx for the review but tell you what, I'll still go ahead and see it in a cinema hall and that is because of the clout Will Smith has in my book; most of his films are good anyway but I especially love him for playing Mohammed Ali in Ali, I like his style of doing comedy as well, the bad boys and men in black movies were all so funny also, I'd love to see Will Smith playing the grudgy alcoholic as well but as you suggested, I think I'll leave after Will takes of to save the woman police officer
    ReplyDelete
  11. I saw it last Thursday. Before I went, I had read all the reviews I could get my hands on at the Rotten Tomatoes site, so I knew about the uneven plot. Because I was prepared, it did not surprise me when it happened. I had even been able to understand why Charlize kept making all those weird faces and giving poignant looks in the first half of the movie. I was even able to predict what the plot twist was going to be. But that does not mean that it made sense. The transition was not well developed, and the change in the story angle was frankly unnecessary.
    ReplyDelete
  12. Thanks for the movie review.I do not think I will waste my money on it.
    ReplyDelete
  13. Love Will Smith. Sorry the movie is just half - a movie!
    ReplyDelete
  14. Beautiful review, I love it. A friend recently told me almost verbatum what you said. However, she did not suggest walking out halfway through. The butt shot tag, hooked me though. Prior to learning about that (thank you), I was going to wait until it came out on DVD.
    ReplyDelete
  15. keep the movie reviews coming.
    you completely nailed this one.
    ReplyDelete
  16. Seems like a lovely public service ‘review’ today! I don’t see many movies any more but my friends go often so I’ll pass the info along ;--)
    Hugs and blessings,
    ReplyDelete
  17. Amen, sister. Agreed with you on everything down to loving Hancock's first share to his most beautiful behind.

    I think the first half is worth seeing for sure. The second half? You're better off switching over to Men in Black...it's at least more logical! ;)
    ReplyDelete